To find out more about the podcast go to âChunks of earth just disappearâ: life on a collapsing island.
Below is a short summary and detailed review of this podcast written by FutureFactual:
Arctic Island in Real Time: Herschel Island's Thaw Slump, Shrubification, and COP30
Leyland Checo travels to Herschel Island, a remote Arctic outpost off Canada's northwest, to document how climate breakdown is reshaping land, sea, and life. The expedition reveals thawing permafrost driving coastal collapse, a rare retrogressive thaw slump, and ecological shifts from shrubification that threaten lichen and caribou. Indigenous Inuvaluit voices frame the urgency as COP30 in Belem, Brazil foregrounds global climate action, underscoring the gap between local observation and policy. This piece connects a single islandâs fate to broader Arctic and planetary warming while highlighting the human stakes for Indigenous communities and researchers.
Introduction
The Guardian Science Weekly report follows Leyland Checoâs expedition to Kikik Taruk, Herschel Island, a remote Arctic site off northwest Canada, to witness climate change in real time. The narrative blends field reporting with expert interviews to illustrate how warming, permafrost thaw, and shifting ecosystems are remaking a place with deep Indigenous significance.
The Journey and Observations
Checoâs journey, including a helicopter transfer and a landing on a shrinking coastline, offers a stark view of Arctic fragility. The fast-moving thaw reveals land collapse, with chunks of terrain tumbling into the sea and the ground losing its ice-anchored support. The landscape hosts beluga, moose, grizzly bears, and musk ox, but beneath the surface the ground is destabilizing as permafrost thaws. One of the islandâs striking features, a retrogressive thaw slump named Slump D, exemplifies the scale of change and its ongoing growth. The soundscape of rushing water and mud-thick subsidence underscores that researchers are witnessing a tipping point in real time.
Ecology, Shrubification, and Tipping Points
Isla Mayer Smith and her Team Shrub study how longer growing seasons and northward shrub expansion alter the Arctic ecology. While greenery can boost biodiversity, it comes with costs: lichenâcrucial forage for caribouâdims as shrubs crowd out open habitats, threatening already pressured herds. Species that rely on barren nesting grounds, like the American golden plover, are also affected as their habitat recedes. The piece emphasizes a broader, accelerating shift toward a tipping point in which multiple species and processes collide with rapid habitat loss and ecological imbalance.
Permafrost Thaw, Data Loss, and Indigenous Perspectives
The permafrost layer, long treated as solid ground, is thawing, causing land to sink and disintegrate. Scientists fear that as the island erodes, decades of data and long-running studies will be lost, complicating efforts to understand long-term Arctic changes. For the Inuvaluit, Herschel Island is not merely a site of research; it is a living landscape central to language, hunting, and life. The narrative underscores the tension between preserving digital records and maintaining a land-based way of life that is inseparable from the terrain itself.
Global Context and COP30
Against the backdrop of COP30 in Belem, the report connects local observations to global policy. Projections warn that even modest temperature increases can trigger cascading effects in the Arctic, including methane release from thawing permafrost. The interviewees express concern over whether global leadership can translate observed Arctic changes into meaningful action to limit warming and protect vulnerable communities.
Conclusion
The piece closes with a sense of unresolved urgency. While Herschel Islandâs fate may be sealed in the face of accelerating climate change, the report reinforces the need for immediate action and sustained, Indigenous-led research to document and respond to Arctic change.
"The island will keep disappearing, but it's hard because I spoke with the scientists and there is nothing hopeful to write about Herschel Island" - Leyland Checo
"Shrubification is changing habitats fast, and it's not just greenery; it's threatening lichen and caribou" - Isla Mayer Smith, Professor of Ecology, University of British Columbia